x88x
06-17-2010, 09:41 AM
So here's the deal. You remember all the crap over the last few years with Comcast throttling..certain things.., the FCC slapping them down, them saying they didn't do anything...them admitting that, ok, yeah, we did that :rolleyes:, and finally the FCC getting shot down by congress when they tried to get some net-neutrality legislation passed? Well, it looks like the industry is just as sick of it as we are, because Verizon, Google, and some other key industry players have formed the 'Broadband Internet Technical Advisory Group' to set standards of neutrality and help deal with infrastructure problems. Basically, it looks like this is their way of saying, "Well, something needs to be done, and since Congress can't be bothered, we'll just do it ourselves.".
I found this quote very interesting:
So, for example, again the Comcast case, if there would have been an industry body, and I don't just mean industry players, I mean also even advocates that have an engineering and technology background, they should be part of the process; so should folks in the academic world. But they should be able to meet regularly and look at some of these issues. So Comcast could have come in and said, 'Look, we've got a congestion problem. It's severe, it's caused, we think, by P2P. How do we deal with this? Have you guys got some ideas, because frankly, the ideas we are thinking about we are not sure are going to work that well.'
I don't know about anyone else, but I think this is a great breath of fresh air and sanity in the information industry. No sneaking around behind each others' backs, just "Hey, there are a lot of smart people around here and in academia...let's put their minds together and see if we can fix these problems we're having." That's the way it should work! :D
EDIT:
Link to original article:
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/06/verizon-comcast-p2p-blocking-was-wrong-we-wont-do-it.ars
I found this quote very interesting:
So, for example, again the Comcast case, if there would have been an industry body, and I don't just mean industry players, I mean also even advocates that have an engineering and technology background, they should be part of the process; so should folks in the academic world. But they should be able to meet regularly and look at some of these issues. So Comcast could have come in and said, 'Look, we've got a congestion problem. It's severe, it's caused, we think, by P2P. How do we deal with this? Have you guys got some ideas, because frankly, the ideas we are thinking about we are not sure are going to work that well.'
I don't know about anyone else, but I think this is a great breath of fresh air and sanity in the information industry. No sneaking around behind each others' backs, just "Hey, there are a lot of smart people around here and in academia...let's put their minds together and see if we can fix these problems we're having." That's the way it should work! :D
EDIT:
Link to original article:
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/06/verizon-comcast-p2p-blocking-was-wrong-we-wont-do-it.ars