Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 28

Thread: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

  1. #11
    iShot the Sheriff jdbnsn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Normal
    Posts
    8,241

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    I am a medical student currently and I would say from the statistics and case studies I have reviewed concerning lead poisoning that yes it is a serious concern when exposed as it is a veracious poison but your level of exposure in this situation would be considerably small. The vast majority of inhalation poisoning that I have seen have been from sanding lead-based paint. Now of course this risk would only be real assuming you used lead-based solder, which is becoming less frequently used do to it's contaminant properties. Most widely available solders are composed of mixtures of tin, silver, and copper. So lead poisoning is really not a viable risk factor here, however, standard precautions should always be used when sanding any materials, this includes metals, plastics, and even wood. Respirators are preferrable, but even one of those tissue masks would suffice. Enough soap boxing for me, just wanted to point out that I wasn't suggesting sanding lead and huffing the vapor, I usually sand metals wet anyway to reduce particles.

  2. #12
    Life is like an analogy...
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Vancouver, BC, Canada
    Posts
    1,235

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    cevinzol, you may very well be right. its been a while since ive sucked on anything with lead in it. i HAVE done it though because im pretty stupid sometimes. i might be thinking of lead compounds in general because the ions might be sweet. i cant remember what it was, but i do remember it being sweet. anyways, im not too concerned about how lead tastes. it was more of a side thought than anything. im more concerned about the ventilation deal, even though its off topic a bit.

    the reason i say i wouldnt worry about ventilation is because lead is pretty heavy (second heaviest stable metal, bismuth being the first). its more likely that any small particles you kick up from sanding will end up on the floor instead of in your body. and besides, its not like you're going to have your face against the metal while sanding, and im pretty sure you arent going to shake out the sand paper right in front of yourself.

    im going to settle this matter definitively tomorrow then. ive got a couple chunks of lead from fishing weights. im going to take a belt sander to them tomorrow in a closed space and ill let you know if i see any dust in the air. of course, dont try it at home for yourself. think of this as an unofficial mythbusters episode, which is being done for the greater good. if i turn out to be wrong in any of this, you have written permission to drive to my house and beat me with whatever object strikes your fancy.


    Quote Originally Posted by Slug Toy
    im pretty sure i was your car, but i was into mah music and didnt think too much of it

  3. #13
    iShot the Sheriff jdbnsn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Normal
    Posts
    8,241

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    HaHaHa....That's takin one for the team! I assume you plan to wear a respirator? Well, if you're going to do it AMA... You should lay large, clean, white sheets of paper on the floor around you to measure how far the particles travel before hitting the ground, that will give you an idea of how well they travel in the air. And to best visualize the particles, lights off with some bright narrow-field lamps beaming across your work area will help. Also hanging long strips of wet white paper from the ceiling down to the level of the sander can show how high the particles had risen. I'm all for scientific endeavors, and I think you understand the risks involved. My only recommendation is protect your airways and eyes, any open cuts, and shower immediately afterward with a strong detergent to remove all particulate lead. You are not likely to suffer a major exposure, but even tiny amounts can find their way into your blood stream through the mouth especially and leave permanent lead collections which damage the brain, peripheral nerves, kidneys, among others. Of course advice is not to proceed, but if you're going to do it, do it safe please.

  4. #14
    Water Cooled
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Posts
    549

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    lead is pretty heavy (second heaviest stable metal, bismuth being the first).
    I'm afraid you've confused Atomic Weight on the periodic table with density. They are not the same.
    Osmium (Atomic Weight= 190.2) is actually the heaviest stable element.
    Nearly twice as heavy a Lead (AW= 207.19).

    Osmium: 22,610 KG/cubic meter
    Gold : 19,300 KG/cubic meter
    Lead : 11,340 KG/cubic meter
    Bismuth: 9,780 KG/cubic meter

    Sorry, I won't de-rail this thread any further.

  5. #15
    Life is like an analogy...
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Vancouver, BC, Canada
    Posts
    1,235

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    ok ive finished my rediculous tests about airborne lead hazards. what a pain that was.

    first, ill get one thing out of the way. yes, i was referring to atomic weight, and not density. i cant really tell you why, but for some reason i dont think density will play an important role at such small particulate sizes, and i believe any metal of similar atomic weight will behave similarly. i may understand chemistry better than the average person, but im not into atomic stuff, so im going on gut feeling.

    ok, now to my test results. i actually did follow your idea, jdbnsn. i had some white construction paper laid out, and i had some fly paper on hand, so i hung some of that around the area. i used a belt sander with various grit sand papers between 200 and 800, and a palm sander with 2000 grit, and also a single cut and double cut file. i heated and froze the metals to see if that had any effect (although highly improbable). i also did more than just lead, so that we may know even more about this issue. i did lead, steel, aluminum, copper, tin, zinc, nickel, silver, gold, cobalt, manganese, bismuth, tungsten, and magnesium. dont ask why or how i have all that, i just do. the results are in point form. i checked after i was done with each metal, so its accurate about the metal, but not really about the specific situation. i checked the fly paper with a jeweler's 10X magnifier, and i averaged the distance any particulate travelled. i also used a brand new mask for each metal, and examined each one with the 10X magnifier as well.

    -lead- particles scattered about 1 inch around work area, no visible dust, and nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -steel- particles scattered about 1.25 inches around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -aluminum- particles scattered about 3 inches around area, fine visible particles, fine dust caught on fly paper about 1.5 feet above area, small amount of powder on mask
    -copper- particles scattered about 1 inch around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -tin- particles scattered about 2.5 inches around area, fine visible particles, fine dust on fly paper about 1.34 feet about area, very small amount of powder of mask
    -zinc- particles scattered about 1.75 inches around area, no visible dust, very fine dust on fly paper about .67 feet above area, very small amount of powder on mask
    -nickel- particles scattered about 1.25 inches around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -silver- particles scattered about 1 inch around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -gold- particles scattered about 1 inch around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -cobalt- particles scattered about 1.25 inches around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, mothing on mask
    -manganese- particles scattered about 1 inch around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -bismuth- particles scattered about 1 inch around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -tungsten- particles scattered about 1 inch around area, no visible dust, nothing on fly paper, nothing on mask
    -magnesium- particles scattered about 1.5 inches around area, fine visible particles, fine dust on fly paper about 1.67 feet above area, small amount on mask

    so there you have it. a lot of stuff happening there. it actually is about what i expected, not the actual distances, but the relative distances.

    so i want to wrap this thing up quick. ill conclude by saying it looks like its more likely you should worry about getting alzheimers from the aluminum in the air. lead just doesnt seem to travel. a couple other metals travel through the air, but im pretty sure they're safe.

    the original question was answered here, so at least we got something meaningful out of this thread. i dont really know if what ive done is meaningful or not to tell the truth. it sure was a morning spent in the name of science/stupidity!


    Quote Originally Posted by Slug Toy
    im pretty sure i was your car, but i was into mah music and didnt think too much of it

  6. #16
    High-tech Redneck crazybillybob's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Currently Homeless
    Posts
    1,028

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    Quote Originally Posted by Cannibal23
    well. seeing as i dont have a torch i will have to go the bondo / epoxy method i guess. so i guess i can fill the minor scratches with the bondo and sand it down. i dont know about the lil over cuts though. what is bondo like some kind of play doh kind of stuff or more liquidly?

    As long as your useing the Bond to "fill" a low spot it doesn't matter if it's a dent or a cut. Just apply the bondo to the area (give it about a 1"-2" over lap on all side, this is a good practice but not possible every where so just wing it), let the bondo dry, and sand it flush. I'll be doing allot of bondo work on metal again soon, when I do I'll get some good pics up in my R2 work log to help explain this better. If you get pin holes (little trapped air bubles that when you sand down to them they leave little divots or bowls in the filled area) in the bondo or you think the scratch is to small for bondo. Pick up some auto body Glaze (made by bondo here in the usa). It's a bit thinner like toothpaste, but you don't want to use it for big stuff because it shrinks allot more then bondo. You can spread the bondo and glaze with a plastic spreader or old beussness cards (the co I work for before, changed it's name 3 times in the 5 yrs I worked there so I have a few "Extras" laying around ) Just make sure you have it a little thicker then the metal or plastic peice, because your going to sand down to it. If the area needs allot of fill remember that sevral thinner coats dry faster and have a lesser chance of craking or pinholeing.

    There's been a allot of talk here about the dangers of lead. But You need to under stand that Bondo is way more dangerous! The Fumes kill brain cells quickly, so do your self a favor and get a good resperator (not those cheapy paper things...they are no good against fumes they only on particles!) You can pick them up for about $20 from Harbor freight, this seems to be the cheapest place to get them. But if you can't wait for them to be shipped (assuming you don't have a local HF) you can get them at your local Hardware (Home despot, and Lowes carry them) just be ready to spend more (up to and over $40, from what other's have stated here @ TBCS). The number one thing is be safe!


    If you have any more Q's on how to fill the dents, scratches, etc just ask.

    Oh, Bondo is cream to pinkish color when dried so you can only do this if your going to paint over it. If you want bare metal, you'll have to pound the dents out and sand everything smooth.

    Good Luck,
    Crazybillybob

  7. #17
    some custom title eh Cannibal23's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Ottawa Ontario Canada
    Posts
    525

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    thanks for the detaild info. i think i will use that paste stuff for the smaller nicks and scratches. seems like it will be esier to work with and the cratches and nicks arent really huge. the over cuts however i found some wicked stuff to use on them. its an epoxy putty. there is 2 parts to it but its all in one stick. the outer layers are one part and the inner core is another part (diffrent colors naturally) so you sqush it togeather and press it into any holes cracks miss drills or whatever that needs filling. the wicked part now is that this stuff can be sanded drilled machined you can even tap this stuff. so there is a good product for some rookies i guess. if you drill the wrong spot you can just fill it in with this and redrill. even if you used the wrong sized bit and need to redrill the same hole you just fill it in wait for it to cure and drill again like nothing ever happend. product details are as follows

    Magic Bond epoxy putty, made by Devcon
    - The stone knows not why the chistle cleves it
    - The steel knows not why the fire scorches it
    - When thy life is cleft and scorched
    - Curse not thine evil fate
    - Thank the builder for the trials that shape thee.

  8. #18
    iShot the Sheriff jdbnsn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Normal
    Posts
    8,241

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    This thread kills me, I laughed so hard when I read this last post, it is absolutely hilarious! We had a simple question, which errupted into a debate over products and safety to the periodic table of elements and even a scientific (actually fairly well conducted) study, with advice ranging from novice to masters. And in the end, he walked down to the hardware store, and found a better solution. I love the creative process!!!

  9. #19
    Rankenphile
    Guest

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    This thread is getting stickied for sure.

  10. #20
    some custom title eh Cannibal23's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Ottawa Ontario Canada
    Posts
    525

    Default Re: how to fix minor errors from grinding and cutting metal

    sorry :-( didnt want to waste anyones time. i just figured that you guys were too busy argueing with eachother to help me with my questions. i appreciate the effort you guys went through to find out what metal is more dense. this was very interesting information.
    - The stone knows not why the chistle cleves it
    - The steel knows not why the fire scorches it
    - When thy life is cleft and scorched
    - Curse not thine evil fate
    - Thank the builder for the trials that shape thee.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •